From Ripon to the Living Room: How Debate Became an Institution

On March 28, 1925, a professor at a small Wisconsin college received the first membership application for an organization that did not yet exist. Bruno E. Jacob had been asked whether there was an honor society for high school debaters. There was not. So he created one.

By the time Jacob retired in 1969, the National Forensic League had grown from nothing to over 1,200 chapters. He had personally visited all 3,100 county seats in the United States, driving 20,000 miles a year on back roads, building an organization that would eventually enroll more than two million members. Today, that organization is called the National Speech and Debate Association, and it remains the largest interscholastic speech and debate organization in the country.

This is the story of how debate became institutionalized in America: professionalized at the college level, extended to high schools nationwide, and eventually broadcast into every living room through the new medium of television. It is a story of expansion and democratization, but also of narrowing and specialization. What began as the center of civic life became an extracurricular activity.

The First Intercollegiate Debates

The transformation began in the 1890s, as the old literary societies gave way to formal intercollegiate competition. The Yale Union, formed in 1890 by students hoping to "resuscitate the interest aroused by the great debating societies of fifty years ago," received an invitation from the Harvard Union for a joint debate. The first informal intercollegiate debate between Harvard and Yale took place on January 14, 1892.

Similar contests followed on the West Coast and in the Midwest. In 1873, a group of public speaking enthusiasts at Knox College had organized the Interstate Oratorical Association, which held yearly competitions. But oratory was not debate. Oratory involved prepared speeches delivered to judges; debate required responding to an opponent in real time. The two activities would eventually merge under the umbrella term "forensics," but they trained different skills.

By 1843, most American universities had shifted from the written cases of earlier disputations to extemporaneous and oral debate. The literary societies had continued this evolution, developing standardized structures: prepared cases followed by extemporaneous rebuttals. The new intercollegiate competitions formalized these practices into rules that could govern competition between schools.

The Honor Societies

Between 1904 and 1911, a flurry of activity led to the establishment of four major honor societies for debate: Phi Alpha Tau (1904), Delta Sigma Rho (1906), Tau Kappa Alpha (1908), and Pi Kappa Delta. These organizations did more than recognize achievement; they created networks that standardized practices across institutions.

Delta Sigma Rho, founded in Chicago on April 13, 1906, became the honor society for large universities and Ivy League institutions. The founding convention included representatives from the University of Michigan, University of Minnesota, University of Iowa, University of Wisconsin, University of Illinois, University of Nebraska, University of Chicago, and Northwestern. Columbia, Harvard, Princeton, and Yale soon joined. The organization's purpose was "to encourage sincere and effective public speaking."

Tau Kappa Alpha, founded in 1908 in Indianapolis, established a system where each state could have only one chapter, making membership highly selective. These two organizations would eventually merge in 1963 to form Delta Sigma Rho-Tau Kappa Alpha.

The honor societies created infrastructure: rules for competitions, standards for membership, networks of coaches and judges. They also created exclusions. When Bates College tried to nominate Arthur Dyer, a Black debater, for membership in Delta Sigma Rho in 1915, the national organization enforced an unwritten policy of segregation. Bates and other Northern colleges fought the policy, but Delta Sigma Rho responded by officially changing its constitution to prohibit Black members. This would not be overturned for decades.

Women Enter the Arena

Women were generally excluded from intercollegiate debate until the 1920s. In 1897, the University of Wisconsin refused to allow female debaters from the University of Iowa to participate in a competition, declaring that "ladies in that capacity do no credit either to themselves or to co-education in general."

The first female debaters in intercollegiate competition came from the University of Indiana, participating in their first debate on May 12, 1921. They faced opposition from men who assumed women would "only be interested in frivolous topics." The assumption proved spectacularly wrong. By 1927, 90% of debate teams had female competitors.

The rapid integration of women into debate suggests something about the activity itself. Unlike athletics, debate required no physical segregation. Unlike many professions, it offered no obvious justification for exclusion once women proved they could compete. The barriers fell not because attitudes changed overnight, but because the evidence of performance was impossible to ignore.

Bruno Jacob's Vision

Competitive debate remained primarily an intercollegiate activity until Bruno E. Jacob changed everything. Born in Valders, Wisconsin, in 1899, Jacob graduated from Manitowoc High School in 1918 and earned a degree in economics from Ripon College in 1922. As a student, he created a pocket handbook called "Suggestions for the Debater." After graduation, he taught social studies and coached debate at Chippewa Falls High School before returning to Ripon College as an assistant professor of speech.

The founding moment came when Jacob received a letter asking whether an honor society existed for high school debaters. It did not. Some state-level organizations existed, like North Carolina's High School Debating Union and the Montana State High-School Debate League, but they only allowed students to compete up to the state level. There was no national infrastructure.

Jacob drafted and circulated a proposal. The National Forensic League welcomed its first member school on March 28, 1925. Within a year, 100 high schools had joined. By 1927, the organization was publishing "The Bulletin," a newsletter that would evolve into today's "Rostrum" magazine.

The National Tournament

In 1930, Jacob proposed a national speech tournament for NFL members. The following year, the first tournament was held at Ripon College, with 49 schools from 17 states in attendance. Miami, Oklahoma, won the first national championship in high school debate.

The timing was remarkable. The Great Depression began in 1929, yet the NFL continued to grow through the 1930s. By 1931, membership had reached 400 chapters. CBS radio carried the championship debate, bringing competitive speech to a national audience for the first time. The activity that had once drawn crowds to town squares now entered homes through the radio speaker.

In 1937, the NFL established a "National Student Congress," a debate event in which students roleplay as members of the United States Congress, drafting and debating legislation. The format connected debate directly to democratic governance, making the civic purpose of the activity explicit.

World War II forced the suspension of the National Tournament, except for Congressional Debate. President Franklin D. Roosevelt sent a letter of commendation for continuing this democratic exercise during wartime. When the tournament returned after the war, 96 contestants from 22 states competed. President Dwight D. Eisenhower sent greetings to Congress when it convened in Denver.

The Pipeline Forms

The NFL created something that had not existed before: a national pipeline from high school debate to college debate to professional life. Students who excelled in NFL competition went on to college debate teams. Coaches developed networks across institutions. A culture formed around competitive success.

The results became visible in the careers of alumni. The organization would eventually count among its members Supreme Court justices Sonia Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson, along with Samuel Alito. Media figures included Oprah Winfrey, Stephen Colbert, Tom Llamas, and Jane Pauley. Politicians spanned the spectrum from Ted Cruz to Elizabeth Warren.

The common thread was not ideology but skill: the ability to research, organize, and present arguments; to think on one's feet; to respond to opposition; to speak clearly under pressure. These skills proved valuable in law, politics, business, entertainment, and journalism. Debate alumni would describe the activity as formative in ways that other extracurriculars were not.

By the 1950s, the NFL had recorded 100,000 individual members. The organization that Jacob had run from the Ripon College campus with part-time student help and volunteer assistance from his family now required full-time staff. In 1950, Jacob resigned his teaching position to devote himself entirely to the League, visiting about 45 states a year.

Television Changes Everything

On September 26, 1960, 70 million Americans watched John F. Kennedy and Richard Nixon face each other in a Chicago television studio. It was the first nationally televised presidential debate. The format was modest by historical standards: eight-minute opening statements, questions from journalists, three-minute closing statements. But the medium was revolutionary.

The Kennedy-Nixon debates became famous for what they revealed about television's power. Nixon arrived exhausted from campaigning, recovering from a recent illness. He wore a gray suit that blended into the background and declined professional makeup. Kennedy had spent a weekend preparing, arrived tanned and rested, and wore a dark suit that stood out on screen. Informal surveys afterward suggested that radio listeners thought Nixon had won, while television viewers gave the victory to Kennedy.

The substance of the debate was largely forgotten. Both candidates emphasized national security, the threat of communism, and the need to strengthen the military. But the image of the sweating, pale Nixon next to the composed, telegenic Kennedy became the story.

Pollsters estimated that approximately 3.4 million voters determined their choice based solely on the debates. Kennedy won the popular vote by about 100,000 votes out of nearly 69 million cast. The debates may have decided the election.

The 16-Year Gap

After 1960, presidential debates disappeared for sixteen years. Nixon refused to participate in 1968 and 1972. The equal time provision of the Communications Act of 1934 required broadcasters who allowed political candidates to speak to give equal time to all legally qualified opponents, including minor party candidates. This created logistical nightmares and gave frontrunners an excuse to decline.

In 1975, the Federal Communications Commission created a loophole. It ruled that debates sponsored by organizations other than the networks, and broadcast in full as "bona fide news events," were exempt from equal time requirements. The League of Women Voters, a nonpartisan organization promoting voting rights, stepped in to fill the void.

The League sponsored the presidential debates in 1976, 1980, and 1984. The 1976 debates between Gerald Ford and Jimmy Carter drew an estimated 69.7 million viewers for the first debate. The single debate between Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan in 1980 drew 80 million viewers, the most-watched event during the League's era.

But the League's independence created friction with campaigns that wanted control over the format. After the 1984 election, the Democratic and Republican parties moved to create their own debate commission. The League challenged this move, arguing that party control would "deprive voters of one of the only chances they have to see the candidates outside of their controlled campaign environment."

In 1987, the parties announced the creation of the Commission on Presidential Debates. The Commission chose the League to sponsor the last presidential debate of 1988 but placed so many restrictions on the format that the League withdrew. League President Nancy Neuman issued a statement: "The League has no intention of becoming an accessory to the hoodwinking of the American public." The demands of the campaigns, she said, "would perpetrate a fraud on the American voter."

The Commission on Presidential Debates, run by the two major parties, sponsored all presidential debates from 1988 through 2020. The debates became more managed, more scripted, and less spontaneous. The format that had evolved from the three-hour Lincoln-Douglas contests was now a 90-minute exchange controlled by campaign negotiators.

What Was Gained and Lost

The period from 1890 to 1960 transformed debate from a dying tradition into a national institution. High school students in small towns could now compete on the same stage as students from major cities. The skills that had once been reserved for the elite were extended to anyone whose school joined the NFL.

By the time Jacob celebrated the NFL's golden anniversary in 1975, the organization had moved into its own building after 50 years on the Ripon College campus. Jacob named the first eleven members of the National Forensic League Hall of Fame, and the league inducted him by acclamation. The Bruno E. Jacob Award is still given at each national tournament to the school that accumulates the most tournament points throughout the year.

But something was also lost. The literary societies had been integrated into campus life, connected to the wider community, and focused on questions of genuine public importance. The new competitive debate became increasingly specialized. Formats evolved that prioritized speed, technical arguments, and competitive success over accessibility and public engagement.

Presidential debates reached enormous audiences but became exercises in image management rather than genuine argumentation. The League of Women Voters' withdrawal in 1988 marked the end of independent debate sponsorship at the presidential level. Debates that had once been civic events became campaign events.

Most significantly, the infrastructure served students but not adults. A young person could debate through high school and college, developing skills that would serve them throughout their careers. But after graduation, there was nothing. The pipeline that Bruno Jacob built ended at the college door.

The Missing Piece

By 1960, the National Forensic League had created a remarkable achievement: a nationwide infrastructure for training young people in the skills of argumentation, public speaking, and critical thinking. The Kennedy-Nixon debates had demonstrated that Americans had an appetite for watching candidates engage with each other directly. The pieces seemed to be in place for a flourishing debate culture.

What did not happen was the extension of this infrastructure to ordinary adult life. There were no local debate clubs for working professionals. No city championships for citizens who wanted to continue developing their skills. No equivalent of recreational sports leagues for argumentation.

The half million students who debated competitively each year graduated into a void. Whatever skills they had developed would atrophy without practice. Whatever community they had built would disperse.

In the next installment, we will examine how debate became a tool for democratization, reaching into urban schools and underserved communities, while simultaneously revealing the depth of the gap between student infrastructure and adult life. The story becomes one of expansion within limits, as debate proved its value again and again without ever breaking free of its educational container.

---

Sources and Further Reading

On the National Speech and Debate Association: "History," National Speech & Debate Association (speechanddebate.org); Wikipedia entries on Bruno E. Jacob and the NSDA; "Throwback Thursday: The History of the National Forensics League," Ripon Press, April 22, 2021.

On Intercollegiate Debate History: Wikipedia, "Competitive debate in the United States"; "Historical Timeline," University of Iowa Debate.

On Delta Sigma Rho and Racial Exclusion: "Recalling when Bates fought, yet benefited from, a racist debate organization," Bates College News, February 28, 2019.

On Women in Debate: Carly Woods on female debaters; Wikipedia, "Competitive debate in the United States."

On the Kennedy-Nixon Debates: "How the Kennedy-Nixon debate changed the world of politics," National Constitution Center; "The Kennedy-Nixon Debates," History.com; "Television in the United States: The Kennedy-Nixon debates," Britannica.

On the Commission on Presidential Debates: "The League of Women Voters and Candidate Debates: A Changing Relationship," League of Women Voters; "League Refuses to 'Help Perpetrate a Fraud,'" LWV press release, October 3, 1988; Wikipedia, "Commission on Presidential Debates."

On Notable Alumni: "Notable Alumni," National Speech & Debate Association; Wikipedia, "List of National Speech and Debate Association members."