Affirmative
Genetic design is a parental right
Enhancement is an extension of every parent's instinct to give their child the best possible life.
Read the affirmative case
- If we can eliminate heritable diseases like Huntington's before birth, the moral case is overwhelming — condemning a child to preventable suffering to preserve a genetic lottery is not neutrality, it is a choice.
- Parents shape children via nutrition, education, environment, and prenatal care already — genetic tools are a more precise extension of the same instinct, not a categorically different act.
- Restricting enhancement while accepting the natural genetic lottery is arbitrary: what principled distinction separates blind fate from deliberate choice when the outcome for the child is the same?
