Participation by side
0 votes · 6 arguments · 0 takes
Equal participation on both sides
Be the first to make your case on camera — 60 seconds, your best argument.
Record a 60-second video making your strongest argument. Others vote and respond.
Declare a side and become findable. When someone opens a matching seat, you hear about it first.
Pick your side
Schedule a round for a later date, or open a video room. Confirm an opponent and the format before starting. Signing in is required.
Live debate for the event "Is Social Media Destroying a Generation?" on superdebate.org.
Social media is specifically engineered to exploit the adolescent brain's sensitivity to social approval. Infinite scroll and notification design were built to maximize engagement, not wellbeing. Meta's own internal research showed the company knew Instagram was harmful to teenage girls' body image and mental health — and chose continued growth over remediation.
Girls' rates of depression and anxiety doubled between 2010 and 2020 across the US, UK, Canada, and Australia simultaneously. That pattern follows smartphone adoption and social media penetration, not economic cycles, political events, or any other candidate explanation. The cross-national, cross-demographic simultaneity is exactly the pattern a single cause would produce.
Blaming the phone serves powerful interests: politicians don't have to fund mental health services, parents don't have to examine household stress, and tech companies pivot to 'safety' features without substantive change. The moral panic serves everyone except the teenagers whose real problems — economic precarity, academic pressure, social isolation — go unaddressed.
The most rigorous pre-registered studies — including Przybylski's work on 350,000 teenagers — find effects of social media on wellbeing smaller than wearing glasses or eating potatoes. The effect sizes largely disappear when controlling for prior mental health history, socioeconomic factors, and reverse causality: depressed teenagers spend more time online.
The solutions are achievable. Age verification, phone-free schools, and redesigning feeds away from social comparison have shown measurable wellbeing improvements where implemented. The only obstacle is political will to act against the lobbying of companies with enormous financial incentive to maintain the status quo.
Mental health deteriorated across the same period in communities with minimal smartphone access, and improved in some communities with heavy use. That pattern is inconsistent with a simple screen-time story and consistent with economic precarity, housing insecurity, academic pressure, and pandemic disruption as primary causes.
Interested in debating this topic live? Tell us how you want to get involved — we reach out to every submission.
