SHOULD WE ABOLISH PRISONS?
General · Real arguments from SuperDebate members below
Both sides of the argument
The case for
States that have invested in education, mental health treatment, and drug rehabilitation consistently outperform high-incarceration states on crime rates. Texas and California both significantly reduced their prison populations in the 2010s through reform legislation and saw crime continue to fall....
Posted by jconnor
The racial composition of American prisons is not a statistical accident. Black men are incarcerated at five times the rate of white men for the same types of offenses. A justice system that produces this outcome consistently across 50 years of reform is not neutral — it is structurally...
Posted by jconnor
Abolition does not mean releasing everyone tomorrow; it means building alternative systems first and transitioning out of mass incarceration as those systems mature. Finland and Norway transformed their prisons into humane rehabilitation environments over decades. The abolitionists' claim is that...
Posted by jconnor
The case against
Prison serves an incapacitation function that no proposed alternative matches. A person who is incarcerated cannot commit new crimes against the public during that period. For serious violent offenders, temporary removal prevents additional victims. No community-based restorative process can...
Posted by jconnor
The abolition movement's own theorists acknowledge that a transition away from prisons requires decades of upstream investment in housing, education, and mental health services. In the absence of those systems, abolition is not a reform — it is a plan to release dangerous people into communities...
Posted by jconnor
Victims of serious crimes have a stake in justice that is not satisfied by restorative circles or community accountability processes alone. The criminal justice system gives victims a structured, state-mediated response to harm rather than the options of private revenge or helplessness. Abolition...
Posted by jconnor
Argue it yourself
Rehearse it
Debate this exact resolution against the AI coach and get scored feedback.
Practice with the coachFrequently asked questions
What is a strong argument for "Should We Abolish Prisons?"?
States that have invested in education, mental health treatment, and drug rehabilitation consistently outperform high-incarceration states on crime rates. Texas and California both significantly reduced their prison populations in the 2010s through reform legislation and saw crime continue to fall.... (Argued by jconnor on SuperDebate.)
What is a strong argument against "Should We Abolish Prisons?"?
Prison serves an incapacitation function that no proposed alternative matches. A person who is incarcerated cannot commit new crimes against the public during that period. For serious violent offenders, temporary removal prevents additional victims. No community-based restorative process can... (Argued by jconnor on SuperDebate.)
Has "Should We Abolish Prisons?" been debated live?
Not yet. Anyone can take a side on the topic page and challenge an opponent to argue it live on SuperDebate.
Where can I debate "Should We Abolish Prisons?"?
On SuperDebate. Post a written argument on the topic page, rehearse the resolution against the AI debate coach, or take it to a live debate night at a club near you. Joining is free.