Affirmative
Incentives drive AI creative investment
Copyright protection incentivizes companies to build AI tools that create genuine value. Without ownership rights, the investment in creative AI collapses — and human artists lose the tools that augment their work.
Read the affirmative case
- The logic of copyright is not about rewarding human creative suffering — it is about incentivizing the production of creative works for public benefit. If AI systems produce valuable creative output, denying copyright creates a collective-action problem: anyone can copy the output instantly, so no company can recoup the cost of building the AI system. The result is less creative AI, not more human creativity.
- The 'human author' requirement is a policy choice, not a natural law. Corporate authorship was invented in the 19th century to allow publishers and studios to hold copyright — not because corporations are creative, but because the law needed to incentivize creative investment. The same logic applies to AI: assign copyright to the company that built the model and directed the creative output.
- Current US Copyright Office guidance creates an absurd gradient: a human who types one sentence directing an AI to generate 10,000 words holds copyright on the whole; a human who generates the same work with slightly less direction holds nothing. This is a doctrinal incoherence that requires a principled framework — and the most principled framework is calibrated to the degree of human creative input, not a binary on/off switch.
