Affirmative
No liability means no safety
Products that harm people create liability for their makers. That is the foundational principle of consumer protection law, and AI is not exempt because the code is probabilistic.
Read the affirmative case
- Product liability law already applies to defective software in medical devices and autonomous vehicles; there is no principled reason that an AI chatbot providing suicide instructions to a depressed teenager should enjoy immunity that a medical device manufacturer does not.
- The EU's experience shows that liability-driven compliance is achievable: companies operating in Europe have built audit trails, redress mechanisms, and human oversight systems that their US equivalents have not, demonstrating that legal pressure produces safety investment.
- The argument that liability will stifle innovation is the same argument made against seatbelt mandates, food safety law, and pharmaceutical clinical trials; in every case, safety requirements improved products rather than killing industries.
