Affirmative
ALLOW: Autonomous systems can fight more precisely
Autonomous systems can be faster, more precise, and less affected by fear, hatred, and exhaustion than human soldiers — potentially making warfare more discriminate, not less.
Read the affirmative case
- Human soldiers are subject to fear, anger, exhaustion, and hatred that degrades their capacity for discrimination — autonomous systems operating by precise rules of engagement could be more compliant with international humanitarian law than the humans they replace.
- Autonomous systems are already deployed in missile defense, electronic warfare, and drone swarms; the question is not whether to allow machine decision-making in warfare but where to draw the line — a blanket prohibition ignores the spectrum that already exists.
- The arms race is happening regardless of whether the US and Europe participate; unilateral disarmament from autonomous weapons development hands the advantage to China and Russia, who will not observe a treaty they aren't party to.
