Affirmative
Break them up
Markets only work when competitors can enter them. When a single company controls both the marketplace and competes on it, or buys every potential rival before it can grow, competition is theater.
Read the affirmative case
- Google paid Apple $12 billion in 2021 alone to be the default search engine on every iPhone. No startup can match that. A market where incumbents can buy defaults and lock out competition is not a functioning market; it is a toll booth. Courts have now confirmed this constitutes illegal monopoly maintenance, and the remedy should match the scale of the harm.
- When Facebook acquired Instagram in 2012 for $1 billion, internal emails showed the acquisition was explicitly motivated by eliminating a competitive threat before it could grow. The FTC's case documents a decade of buy-rather-than-compete strategy. Allowing acquisitions of nascent competitors forecloses exactly the kind of innovation that antitrust law was designed to protect.
- Network effects create winner-take-all dynamics that do not self-correct through normal market mechanisms. The network that every person is on is more valuable to each user than a better-quality network with fewer members. Antitrust intervention is the only known mechanism that can break a network-effect monopoly, and the US has used it successfully before with AT&T and Standard Oil.
