Affirmative
Polluters must pay
Climate attribution science can now quantify which nations' emissions caused specific disasters; combining that with documented damages creates the same liability chain that underlies any tort claim.
Read the affirmative case
- Climate attribution science can now calculate, to within a few percentage points, which nations' historical emissions caused specific extreme weather events, including the 2022 Pakistan floods and the 2023 Libya flooding, creating a legally coherent basis for damages claims that did not exist a decade ago.
- The 'common but differentiated responsibilities' principle in the UNFCCC already acknowledges that wealthy, high-emitting nations bear special obligations; reparations are the logical extension of a principle all parties have already accepted.
- Aid framed as charity can be reduced or eliminated by any new government; legal reparations create binding obligations that survive elections, giving vulnerable nations the financial certainty needed to plan multi-decade adaptation investments.
