Affirmative
Speech doesn't stop being speech because a corporation says it
Corporations are associations of people. Denying them constitutional rights would allow government to suppress the political speech of unions, nonprofits, and media companies — many of which are corporations.
Read the affirmative case
- The New York Times Company is a corporation. The NAACP is a nonprofit corporation. The Sierra Club, the NRA, the AFL-CIO are all incorporated entities. A constitutional regime that denies corporations First Amendment protection empowers government to silence these organizations. Citizens United was not just about corporate money; it was about whether the government could ban a film critical of Hillary Clinton. The answer — no — is correct.
- Constitutional protections for corporations run deeper than Citizens United. The Fourth Amendment protection against warrantless search of corporate premises protects trade secrets and employee privacy. The Fifth Amendment protection against self-incrimination protects corporate records. Stripping these protections would give the government sweeping investigative power over businesses — a tool with obvious potential for abuse against political opponents.
- The legal concept of corporate personhood predates Citizens United by 200 years and underpins contract law, property law, and the ability to sue and be sued. Corporations as legal persons can be held liable for wrongdoing, enter binding agreements, and own property — all of which is essential to a functioning market economy. The question is not whether corporations should have legal personhood, but which constitutional rights should attach — a question of line-drawing, not abolition.
