Affirmative
Your data is yours
Personal data is an extension of personal autonomy. Allowing it to be sold without consent creates a surveillance economy in which individuals are the product, not the customer.
Read the affirmative case
- Data brokers compile profiles on virtually every American adult — including location history, purchase behavior, health conditions inferred from search history, political affiliation, and financial stress indicators — and sell them without consent. This data is used to price insurance, target political advertising, screen employment applications, and set bail recommendations. The downstream harms are concrete and well-documented; the individual whose data was sold has no recourse.
- The European Union's GDPR, in force since 2018, prohibits data collection and sale without affirmative consent and has not destroyed the European internet economy. EU companies have adapted to consent requirements; compliance costs are real but manageable. The claim that privacy protection is economically ruinous is a lobbying argument by the data broker industry, not an empirical finding.
- Health and location data sold without consent has been used to track abortion patients, identify people attending political protests, and profile members of religious minorities. These are not hypothetical harms: the Senate Intelligence Committee documented in 2024 that US data brokers sold location data from mobile phones near sensitive federal facilities to foreign intelligence services. A ban addresses a genuine national security risk, not just individual privacy.
