Affirmative
Informed votes are better votes
Democracy asks us to treat all votes as equal regardless of the information behind them; epistocracy asks whether that is actually fair to people who study the issues.
Read the affirmative case
- Voters are systematically ignorant of basic political facts — most can't name their representative, the three branches of government, or basic party policies; collective decisions made on this basis are not the wisdom of crowds but its opposite.
- Competence conditions already exist: we require a driver's license to drive, a bar exam to practice law, a medical license to prescribe drugs; it's not obvious why the most consequential collective decision — government — should be the one with no competence requirement.
- Giving more weight to informed votes doesn't necessarily mean removing rights from the ignorant; weighted voting, citizens' assemblies, and deliberative mini-publics are epistocratic reforms that improve decision quality without disenfranchisement.
