Affirmative
Zoning is the root of the housing crisis
Making it illegal to build apartments in most of a city is the proximate cause of the affordability crisis. Supply restrictions inflate prices; legalizing density is the fastest path to affordability.
Read the affirmative case
- Minneapolis abolished single-family zoning citywide in 2020. In the three years following, building permits issued increased 53% and rent growth in Minneapolis was slower than in comparable Midwest cities. California's 2021 statewide law (SB 9) allowing duplexes on any residential lot is the largest natural experiment in zoning reform in US history — early evidence shows it is increasing supply without the mass neighborhood displacement critics predicted.
- Single-family zoning was historically used as a tool of racial segregation: explicit racial covenants were unenforceable after 1948, but zoning kept Black and immigrant families out of majority-white neighborhoods by making land too expensive for apartments. The wealth gap between homeowners and renters — which closely tracks racial wealth disparities — is partly a product of 80 years of exclusionary zoning that constrained housing supply in appreciating markets.
- The math is simple: in cities with fixed housing supply and growing populations, prices must rise. San Francisco permitted fewer homes in the decade of the 2010s than it had residents. The result is median rents exceeding $3,000/month. Every study on housing supply finds the same relationship: more supply moderates price growth. Zoning is the legal barrier to supply — abolishing it is the mechanism of relief.
