MICHAEL JORDANvsLEBRON JAMES
The SuperDebate
Persuasion over volume. Evidence over noise. Cross-examination over hot takes.
Two trained debaters take on the most relitigated question in basketball — in a real debate format.
Recording: weekend of May 30, 2026 · Debut: first week of June 2026
The Concept
The biggest basketball argument of all time — argued for real
Two trained debaters take on the most relitigated question in basketball through structured argument. Neither is emotionally invested. Both are sharp on craft. The hook is the contrast: persuasion over volume, evidence over noise, cross-examination over hot takes.
The angle is simple: what happens when elite debaters formally debate the biggest basketball argument of all time. The goal is to introduce new audiences to debate in a format that feels modern, accessible, and fun.
The Resolution
“Resolved: Michael Jordan is the greatest basketball player of all time.”
Persuasion over volume
Two debaters with no fandom on the line. The rhetoric does the work.
Evidence over noise
Stats, careers, eras — structured arguments, not vibes.
Cross-ex over hot takes
Two cross-examination rounds force claims to survive direct pressure.
Audience scores the result
After release, viewers score persuasiveness, evidence, cross-ex, rebuttal, and overall effectiveness.
Who's Debating
Elite craft debaters. No emotional stake in basketball.
Lindsay Duede
Pro-Jordan
IPDA national champion and coach of the 2026 varsity national champion. Builds tight, evidence-driven cases.
AffirmativeIain Lampert
Pro-LeBron
Veteran debater making the modern case. Cross-examination is where his arguments tend to land.
NegativeMatthew Rolnick
Emcee & moderator
Runs the room. Keeps the run-of-show tight, calls the clock, and runs the lightning round.
ModeratorJohn Connor
Format primer
Founder, SuperDebate. Two minutes on why this format makes for sharper arguments than the usual panel.
HostThe Format
Modified for sharper clips, tighter pressure, and YouTube retention
Intro and context
Matthew
Format primer
John
Opening statement
Lindsay (Pro-Jordan)
Cross-examination
Iain questions Lindsay
Opening statement
Iain (Pro-LeBron)
Cross-examination
Lindsay questions Iain
Rebuttal
Lindsay (Pro-Jordan)
Rebuttal
Iain (Pro-LeBron)
Lightning round
Both, moderated by Matthew
Closing statement
Lindsay (Pro-Jordan)
Closing statement
Iain (Pro-LeBron)
Watch It
Pick one — or both — and we'll send the link.
LIVE · MAY 30, 2026
Watch the recording live
Recorded on the SuperDebate platform with a public audience. We'll email the live link a few hours before showtime.
PUBLISHED · FIRST WEEK OF JUNE 2026
Get the polished cut
One email when the long-form video and analysis post. No live commitment, just the finished thing in your inbox.
Recording window is the weekend of May 30, 2026 — exact slot confirmed by email a few days out. Free either way.
Frequently Asked Questions
Explore More
Discover more events, resources, and ways to get involved with SuperDebate