Affirmative
DEFEND: Rewarding merit is still our best system
Imperfect as it is, rewarding talent and effort is fairer than any alternative and drives the excellence that benefits everyone.
Read the affirmative case
- The alternative to rewarding merit — rewarding birth, seniority, or random selection — produces corrupt institutions and mediocre public services.
- Social mobility data is flawed; US mobility is lower not because meritocracy is broken but because barriers exist that could be fixed without abandoning merit as a principle.
- Meritocracy's critics tend to be highly credentialed people attacking the system that elevated them; the solution is better-designed meritocracy, not egalitarianism.
