Affirmative
Existence guarantees eventual use
Every weapon ever invented has eventually been used. A technology that can end civilization cannot be safely managed forever by fallible institutions, imperfect humans, and degrading systems.
Read the affirmative case
- There have been at least 13 documented near-misses since 1945 — incidents where a misread radar, a communication failure, or a single officer's judgment was the only barrier between a false alarm and nuclear war. The 1983 Petrov incident, the 1995 Norwegian rocket launch, and the 1983 Able Archer exercise each nearly triggered exchanges. Probability compounds over time: if each decade has a 1-in-50 chance of accidental launch, the century-level risk is substantial.
- The Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons, adopted by 68 countries in 2021, reflects a growing international consensus that deterrence is a temporary holding pattern, not a permanent solution. The International Court of Justice ruled in 1996 that the threat or use of nuclear weapons is generally incompatible with international humanitarian law. The moral case for elimination has clear legal precedent.
- Global nuclear disarmament would free roughly $100 billion per year currently spent on maintaining, modernizing, and securing nuclear arsenals. The US alone plans to spend $1.7 trillion on nuclear modernization through 2046. That capital could fund climate adaptation, pandemic preparedness, and poverty reduction — goods that reduce the root causes of conflict without the civilizational risk.
