Affirmative
Freedom of movement is a basic right
Freedom of movement is the single most powerful poverty-reduction tool ever identified — doubling world GDP in a generation according to some economists — and we forgo it because of where people were born.
Read the affirmative case
- Economists across the ideological spectrum estimate open borders would roughly double world GDP by allowing labor to flow to its highest-value use — it is the most efficient anti-poverty intervention imaginable, and the main argument against it is nationalism, not economics.
- The right to move is already recognized for goods, capital, and data; restricting it for people but not the products they make or money they earn is an arbitrary asymmetry that protects incumbent workers in wealthy countries.
- Every moral intuition that condemns discrimination by race, religion, or gender should also condemn discrimination by birthplace; the passport lottery is the most consequential determinant of life outcomes and the least morally defensible.
