Affirmative
Every child deserves school choice
Zip code should not determine a child's school quality. Public funds should follow the student, not the institution — giving every family the access to educational alternatives that wealthy families already have.
Read the affirmative case
- A 2021 study of Milwaukee's voucher program — the oldest in the country — found that students who used vouchers to attend private schools had graduation rates 14 percentage points higher than comparable public school students. Empirical reviews of voucher programs in DC, Indiana, and Louisiana find positive graduation effects even when test-score effects are modest. Long-run outcomes are what matter — and the evidence on those is favorable.
- Wealthy families can already choose their children's schools by choosing their neighborhood or paying private tuition. Education savings accounts extend that choice to families without the means to move to a high-performing district or pay out-of-pocket. The equity argument for choice is strong: the families most harmed by the assignment of children to schools based on address are those who cannot afford to change their address.
- Competition improves outcomes. Swedish evidence and US charter school data show that when schools must attract students to survive, their instructional quality and student satisfaction improve. Public schools in Milwaukee and DC that faced the most competition from voucher programs showed measurable academic improvement — the market mechanism works even for public institutions.
