Affirmative
RESEARCH: We need this option on the table
If emissions reductions fail — as they are currently failing — solar geoengineering is the only technology that could cool the planet fast enough to prevent catastrophic warming; not researching it is a choice to die rather than try.
Read the affirmative case
- We are not on track to meet 1.5°C or even 2°C; stratospheric aerosol injection is the only technology that could meaningfully reduce temperatures within years, not decades; responsible research is necessary to understand whether and how it might be used if needed.
- The research community is not proposing deployment but field trials to understand atmospheric behavior; blocking outdoor experiments on precautionary grounds is epistemically self-defeating — we can't know if it works without testing it.
- We already geoengineer inadvertently through aviation contrails and shipping sulfur emissions; intentional and controlled understanding is better than inadvertent and unmanaged intervention in a system we're already perturbing.
